The Best Online Seafood Delivery Services Available in 2025

Seafood delivery in 2025 isn’t just a trend—it’s how more people are getting high-quality fish at home without the guesswork. From sushi nights to quick weeknight dinners, having seafood shipped directly to your door has never been easier—or more diverse.

But with so many companies offering everything from wild-caught salmon to live lobster and sashimi-grade tuna, how do you know which one fits your needs best? In this guide, we explore the most trusted seafood delivery services available today—and what to look for when choosing one that matches your taste, values, and budget.

What’s the Best Seafood Delivery Service Overall?

Trying to decide where to start with seafood delivery? Fulton Fish Market is a solid choice, especially if variety is your priority. With over 200 years of history, this marketplace offers one of the most extensive selections of seafood online—from wild-caught and responsibly sourced fish to lobster, caviar, and more. Their platform works for both home cooks and professional chefs, with options to shop à la carte or subscribe to curated seafood boxes delivered weekly, biweekly, or monthly.

What sets Fulton apart is its size and flexibility. Their online store features everything from Atlantic salmon to sushi-grade tuna and oysters. Orders over $125 ship free, and new subscribers can enjoy perks like $25 off and free seafood add-ons for a year on select plans.

Still, Fulton isn’t for everyone. If you're specifically looking for premium, wild-caught salmon and whitefish with a traceable source, Alaskan Salmon Company might be a better fit. More on that below.

Alaskan Salmon Company - Best for Ordering Wild-Caught Salmon, Black Cod, and Halibut Online

We take pride in delivering premium wild-caught fish straight from Alaska’s pristine waters to your doorstep. As a commercial fisherman, I started Alaskan Salmon Company to share the kind of seafood I trust for my own family—wild-caught, responsibly sourced, and handled with care every step of the way. From day one, I built this company around the values that matter most to me: quality you can taste, sustainability you can count on, and full transparency from catch to kitchen. Each cut of sushi-grade fish is hand-trimmed and flash-frozen at peak freshness to lock in restaurant-quality taste.

We offer wild-caught sockeye salmon, black cod (sablefish), halibut, and a rotating seasonal box. Our flexible subscriptions let you choose between 12 or 24 six-ounce portions, delivered monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly. Subscribers get early access to exclusive catches, guaranteed shipping even during peak seasons, and the ability to swap or gift items.

Every order reflects our dedication to responsible sourcing. All of our seafood comes from well-managed wild fisheries in Alaska to ensure the long-term health of the oceans and the communities that rely on them. From catch to kitchen, we focus on quality you can trace—and taste.

Pricing & Promotions: Our Premium Fish Variety Gift Box starts at $209, and Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon fillets at $198. We frequently offer promotions, including $25 off sitewide and discounts up to 40% on select items.

LobsterAnywhere - Best for Ordering Lobster Online

LobsterAnywhere is one of the most trusted online seafood retailers for live Maine lobsters. Based in Massachusetts, the company has been shipping fresh, hard-shell lobsters across the U.S. for over two decades. Their lobsters are sourced directly from the cold North Atlantic waters off the Maine coast, which are known for producing sweeter, firmer meat than soft-shell varieties.

In addition to whole live lobsters, LobsterAnywhere offers lobster tails, frozen lobster meat, scallops, shrimp, bisques, chowders, and full surf & turf dinner kits. Many of their products come in gift-ready boxes that include bibs, seafood crackers, and easy-to-follow cooking instructions—making them a popular choice for holidays, celebrations, and gourmet gifts.

There’s no subscription required, so you can order anytime. Most items ship overnight in insulated packaging with gel packs and seaweed to preserve quality and freshness. Prices for live lobsters typically range from $40 to over $80 depending on size, and many gift packages include free overnight shipping. Customers can also join their Sand Dollars Rewards Program to earn credits toward future purchases.

Thousands of customers praise LobsterAnywhere for its reliable service, responsive support, and the restaurant-quality flavor of its lobster—delivered fresh to your door.

Riviera Seafood Club - Best for Ordering Sushi-Grade Fish

Riviera Seafood Club, a family-run business in Los Angeles, specializes in premium, sushi-grade seafood sourced from trusted suppliers. Their selection includes Bluefin tuna (Otoro, Chu-Toro), Ōra King salmon, yellowtail, uni, and more—all handled with care to meet sashimi standards.

They use superfrozen technology to preserve texture and freshness, then ship nationwide in insulated packaging with dry ice. Orders over $175 ship free (or $125 in Southern California), and there's no subscription required—though their auto-ship option saves 5%. Customers can also use discount codes like SMS10 and FLIFE at checkout.

Perfect for at-home sushi nights or special occasions, Riviera has become a go-to for chefs and home cooks alike.

Sea to Table - Best for Ordering Sustainable Seafood

Sea to Table is a family-run seafood company that partners exclusively with independent U.S. fishermen to deliver 100% wild-caught, domestic seafood. Their offerings include Atlantic cod, Gulf shrimp, Alaskan halibut, scallops, skate, and more—all traceable back to the dock and boat they came from.

Each order includes a traceability label detailing the species, where and how it was caught, and who caught it—giving you full transparency and peace of mind. The seafood is flash-frozen at peak freshness and packed with dry ice to ensure safe, cold delivery anywhere in the U.S.

Customers can make one-time purchases or opt into flexible subscription plans (every 4, 6, or 8 weeks). Orders over $99 ship free, and the company offers a 30-day satisfaction guarantee. Whether you’re looking for sustainability, traceability, or just dependable quality, Sea to Table delivers on all fronts.

Seafood Delivery Service FAQs

What type of seafood can you order online?

You can order a wide variety of seafood online, including wild-caught fish like salmon, tuna, and cod, as well as shellfish such as shrimp, scallops, and lobster. Many services also offer sushi-grade fish, clams, mussels, crab, octopus, squid, and even sea urchin. Premium options like bluefin tuna, halibut, and black cod are also available through specialty retailers.

Are online seafood delivery fresh?

Yes, most seafood delivery companies flash-freeze their products at peak freshness or ship them fresh with dry ice. Some include traceability labels so you can track where and when your seafood was caught. These methods ensure your order arrives safely, fresh, and flavorful.

How do seafood delivery ship your order?

Orders are packed in insulated containers with dry ice or gel packs to maintain temperature. Most are vacuum-sealed to preserve freshness and shipped overnight or via express delivery to minimize transit time. This ensures your seafood arrives in excellent condition, ready to cook or serve.

Summary

In 2025, seafood delivery services continue to raise the bar for quality, convenience, and variety. From curated lobster kits and sushi-grade tuna to sustainable U.S.-caught fish, each service on this list brings something unique to the table.