10 Best Seafood Delivery Services in 2024

It’s no secret that getting high-quality seafood can be challenging, especially since many factors affect the freshness and quality of seafood by the time it reaches your local grocery store. This includes transportation time, storage conditions, and the handling process.

Seafood online delivery services can address this challenge by sourcing seafood directly from fishermen and coastal suppliers. Additionally, most of these services are transparent about the origin of the seafood, the fishing methods used, and sustainability practices. All these things allow you to enjoy seafood to the fullest.

This article presents a list of services for a hassle-free seafood experience.

10  Best Seafood Online Delivery Services

• Best Overall: Vital Choice
• Best for Sustainability: Lummi Island Wild
• Best for Salmon: Alaskan Salmon Company
• Best for Lobster: LobsterAnywhere
• Best for Crab: Cameron’s Seafood
• Best for Convenience: Sizzlefish
• Best for Variety: Fulton Fish Market
• Best for Shellfish: Taylor Shellfish Farms
• Best for Affordable Options: Thrive Market
• Best for Best for Busy Individuals: Fish Fixe

1. Vital Choice - Best Overall Quality

Vital Choice is a premium online seafood delivery service that offers a wide range of high-quality, wild-caught, and sustainably sourced seafood. They are renowned for their commitment to health, sustainability, and exceptional taste.

They use flash-freezing techniques to preserve the freshness and flavor of their seafood. This process locks in nutrients and maintains the taste so that customers receive seafood that tastes as if it were just caught.

2. Lummi Island Wild - Best for Sustainability

Lummi Island Wild is a seafood delivery service specializing in sustainably sourced seafood from the Pacific Northwest. They use a traditional method called reefnet fishing, which involves setting up stationary nets that allow fish to swim freely until they are selectively harvested. It minimizes bycatch and reduces the impact on the surrounding marine environment.

Beyond fish, Lummi Island Wild offers bone broth, which is nutrient-dense, made from wild-caught fish bones, and includes various aromatic ingredients for added flavor and health benefits.

3. Alaskan Salmon Company

Backed by Michelin-starred chefs, Alaskan Salmon Company is a revered sustainable option for getting high-quality salmon delivered straight to your doorstep. Alaskan Salmon Company’s products are wild-caught and responsibly harvested, free from pesticides and other chemicals.

Buyers get appointed a personal fisherman, who catches your seafood to order, employing low-impact methods from the best Alaskan waters. You can select from wild-caught salmon, black cod, and halibut boxes, among others, or curate your own box.

4. LobsterAnywhere - Best for Lobster

LobsterAnywhere stands out as the ultimate destination for ordering lobster online, as it offers seafood enthusiasts an excellent experience of indulging in the finest and freshest lobster delicacies.

The company sources its hard-shell lobsters directly from the cold waters of Maine to ensure unparalleled taste and tenderness. Their online platform provides a comprehensive selection of lobster options, including live lobsters, lobster tails, and lobster meat — all accompanied by detailed product descriptions and cooking instructions.

5. Cameron’s Seafood - Best for Crab

Founded in 1985 and based in Maryland, a region renowned for its seafood (especially blue crabs), Cameron’s Seafood has developed expertise in handling and preparing crab.

They emphasize rigorous quality control measures so that their crab products meet high standards. This includes proper handling, storage, and preparation to maintain the best taste and texture! You can also try their other seafood products, such as shrimp and oysters.

6. Sizzlefish - Best for Convenience

Sizzlefish is known for its convenient seafood options, which makes it a top choice for those who prioritize ease and quick meal preparation. Sizzlefish's mission is straightforward: to help customers eat well and live better by providing seafood that supports your health and wellness goals.

Their products include a variety of fish and shellfish, and these are available in individually portioned servings. Note that most of Sizzlefish's fish offerings are wild-caught, although the Atlantic salmon, rainbow trout, and catfish are farmed species.

7. Fulton Fish Market - Best for Variety

Fulton Fish Market has over a century of experience in the seafood industry — it’s one of the oldest and most established seafood markets in the U.S. It serves as a major seafood distributor, as it supplies a wide range of seafood to restaurants, retailers, and consumers!

Whether you’re looking for fish, shellfish, or specialty items, Fulton Fish Market offers them. Moreover, they emphasize that their seafood is procured from well-managed wild fisheries and sustainable aquaculture producers.

8. Taylor Shellfish Farms - Best for Shellfish

Taylor Shellfish Farms specializes in a wide range of shellfish, including oysters, clams, mussels, and geoduck. With over a century of experience, Taylor Shellfish Farms has deep expertise in shellfish farming and harvesting. This long history contributes to their reputation for high-quality products!

The company is committed to sustainable aquaculture practices. They focus on responsible farming techniques that protect marine ecosystems and preserve the long-term health of shellfish populations.

9. Thrive Market - Best for Affordable Options

Founded in 2014, Thrive Market offers a selection of seafood products that are both affordable and adhere to sustainable practices, which aligns with their commitment to ethical sourcing.

As an online marketplace, Thrive Market provides the convenience of shopping for seafood from home. Members can access a range of affordable seafood options like frozen fish and shellfish without needing to visit multiple stores.

10. Fish Fixe - Best for Best for Busy Individuals

Fish Fixe is recognized as a top choice for individuals seeking convenient seafood solutions. The company operates primarily online, and it specializes in delivering pre-portioned, ready-to-cook seafood meal kits directly to consumers.

Consumers can keep the meal kits in their freezer until they’re ready to cook, which is ideal for those with busy schedules. Each meal kit comes with clear, step-by-step cooking instructions, which helps reduce the time and effort needed to prepare a meal!

Conclusion

Seafood subscription services have changed how we enjoy fresh seafood by delivering it straight to our doorsteps. Ordering seafood online has now become a convenient way to enjoy premium offerings like lobster, crab, and assorted fish.

If you’re looking for wild-caught and responsibly harvested salmon, choose Alaskan Salmon Company. Try our offerings today and elevate your meals with the best in seafood.