Skip the Grocery Store — Here’s the Best Online Seafood Delivery Right Now
Updated on May 02, 2025
Seafood doesn’t have to mean a trip to the grocery store. These days, we can order fresh fish, salmon, or even sushi-grade seafood right to our door.
We tried various seafood delivery services to determine which ones were truly worth it, and the results surprised us. Some are best suited for those who love salmon, others excel with shellfish, and a few offer an amazing variety or sustainable choices.
Whether you want the very best overall, a budget-friendly option, or a fun subscription box, we found the top picks to make seafood nights at home delicious and easy.
TL;DR: Best Online Seafood Delivery by Category
- Best Online Seafood Delivery Overall - Citarella
- Best for Value – Fulton Fish Market
- Best for Salmon Lovers - Alaskan Salmon Company
- Best for Shellfish – Browne Trading Company
- Best for Sushi-Grade Fish - Honolulu Fish Company
- Best Sustainable Choice – Wild Alaskan Company
- Best for Variety – Sea to Table
- Best Seafood Subscription Box – Vital Choice Seafood
Best Online Seafood Delivery - Citarella
Citarella is a renowned New York-based fishmonger with over 40 years of experience. They offer a wide selection of fresh seafood, including fish, shellfish, and prepared dishes, all shipped overnight to ensure peak freshness.
Pros:
- Extensive selection of premium seafood
- Overnight shipping for maximum freshness
- Expertly prepared and packaged products
Cons:
- Higher price point compared to some competitors
- Delivery fees can be significant, depending on location
Pricing:
- Fresh fish portions range from $20 to $50
- Prepared seafood dishes start at $30
- Shipping costs vary based on delivery zone; overnight shipping is available for an additional fee
Best for Value – Fulton Fish Market
Founded in 1822, Fulton Fish Market has been a cornerstone of New York City’s food culture for over 200 years. Once a bustling hub at South Street Seaport, the market is now located in the Bronx, where it receives nearly two million pounds of seafood every day. Today, Fulton brings that same tradition and expertise straight to your door, offering fresh and frozen fish, shellfish, and specialty items with nationwide shipping.
Pros:
- Large selection of seafood at competitive prices
- Easy-to-navigate website with customizable subscription options
- Free shipping on orders over $125
Cons:
- Fish ships frozen, which may not appeal to those seeking fresh options
- $75 minimum order requirement
Pricing:
- Frozen seafood bundles start at $50
- Individual portions range from $10 to $30
- Subscription options available with varying price points
Best for Salmon Lovers - Alaskan Salmon Company
Alaskan Salmon Company was born from my time as a commercial fisherman, where I saw firsthand how much better our catch in Alaska was compared to what ended up in stores. Instead of seafood passing through countless middlemen, I set out to connect people directly with fishermen from Alaska’s top ports.
Every fillet is sustainably caught and quickly flash frozen to lock in flavor and texture. The same salmon trusted by Michelin-starred chefs is now delivered nationwide, so you can experience true Alaskan quality at home.
Pros:
- High-quality, wild-caught salmon
- Various cuts and portion sizes available
- Direct-to-consumer shipping ensures freshness
Cons:
- Limited variety compared to other seafood delivery services
- Higher price point for premium cuts
Pricing:
- Starts at $13.38 per filet
- Subscription options available with varying price points
Best for Shellfish – Browne Trading Company
Founded in 1991 by seafood expert Rod Browne Mitchell, Browne Trading Company has grown into a trusted source for premium caviar, fresh fish, shellfish, and smoked seafood. Based in Portland, Maine’s historic fishing district, the company is known for its commitment to quality, transparency, and traceability — supplying both top restaurants and home chefs nationwide.
Pros:
- Offers a wide selection of premium shellfish and caviar
- Next-day delivery available for most orders
- High-quality, sustainably sourced products
Cons:
- Premium pricing for top-tier products
- Minimum order requirements for certain items
Pricing:
- Shellfish items like oysters and clams range from $60 to $100 per order
- Caviar prices vary widely based on type and quantity
Best for Sushi-Grade Fish - Honolulu Fish Company
Honolulu Fish Company delivers sushi-grade seafood straight from Hawaii’s waters to your doorstep. Their fish are wild-caught in the pristine Pacific surrounding the Hawaiian Islands, where sustainable practices and traditional methods ensure both quality and care for the environment.
Pros:
- Ethically caught, sushi-grade fish
- Direct shipping from fishermen ensures freshness
- Free shipping on orders over $180
Cons:
- Expensive shipping on small orders
- Larger cuts may not be suitable for smaller households
Pricing:
- Sushi-grade fish portions range from $30 to $70
- Shipping costs $65 for orders under $180; free shipping on orders over $180
Best Sustainable Choice – Wild Alaskan Company
Wild Alaskan Company makes it easy to enjoy premium, sustainably sourced seafood with a subscription service that brings wild-caught fish straight from Alaska and the Pacific Northwest to your door. Beyond convenience, the company is guided by a deep respect for nature and a commitment to long-term sustainability.
Pros:
- 100% wild-caught, never farmed
- No antibiotics, GMOs, or additives
- Frozen at peak freshness for convenience
Cons:
- Fish ships frozen, which may not appeal to all customers
- Subscription model may not suit those seeking one-time purchases
Pricing:
- Subscription boxes start at $155 per month for 12 servings
- Additional discounts may be available for first-time customers
Best for Variety – Sea to Table
Sea to Table brings the flavor of America’s coasts straight to your kitchen with a wide selection of flash-frozen, wild-caught seafood. Partnering with well-managed U.S. fisheries, they work directly with fishing communities across the country — supporting the men and women who have harvested and protected these waters for generations. Their mission is simple: to help Americans eat better fish.
Pros:
- Wide variety of seafood options
- Commitment to sustainability and traceability
- Flexible subscription plans
Cons:
- Higher price point compared to some competitors
- Shipping costs can be significant for smaller orders
Pricing:
- Subscription plans start at $99 per month
- Shipping is free on orders over $99; flat rate shipping applies to smaller orders
Best Seafood Subscription Box – Vital Choice Seafood
Founded in 2001 on the belief that wild Alaskan salmon is one of nature’s most perfect foods, Vital Choice has grown into a trusted source for premium wild-caught seafood from responsibly managed fisheries around the world. Their subscription boxes feature a rotating selection of salmon, tuna, halibut, scallops, and more — flash frozen to lock in flavor and nutrients.
Pros:
- High-quality, sustainably sourced seafood
- Flexible subscription options
- Convenient, pre-portioned servings
Cons:
- Higher price point for premium products
- Subscription model may not suit those seeking one-time purchases
Pricing:
- Wild Fish: $169.99 (monthly)
- Wild Catch-of-the-Month: $89.99 (monthly)
Skip the Grocery Line – Order Your Seafood Online
Ordering seafood online has never been easier. These delivery services make it possible to enjoy top-quality seafood without leaving home.
Each one has its own strengths, from variety to value — but if you’re a salmon lover, we especially recommend Alaskan Salmon Company. Our Wild King Salmon and Wild Sockeye Salmon are sustainably caught and chef-trusted, so you can enjoy restaurant-quality seafood at home!
